I do not feel comfortable without a book nearby (a print book, that is). And the older I get, the more books I read at the same time; Usually I’m In the midst of two or three. This is no boast, Because I’ve religiously avoided reading serious literature eversince the Course That required me to read Nausea and The Death of Ivan Illyich in the same week. Now I read mostly mysteries-which I could argue are, in fact, serious literature, but I do not Because then I would not want to read them anymore. I get a lot of paperbacks from Amazon, especial since I recently Discovered how cheaply I can get used paperbacks there (I ook get lots of used paperbacks from the Harvard Bookstore in the interest of supporting brick and mortar bookstores.)
Then one of my favorite mystery writers released a novella only in a Kindle version available through Amazon. I broke down, downloaded the Kindle app to my laptop, bought the novella, and read it online. For me, it was an empty experience. I did not enjoy it as much as the Nearly print books by this author. The words just child or lay there on the screen, and I found the annoying glare (I experience this Constantly in my work, but it felt worse when i was reading for fun). I have not bought any more ebooks. I have been trying to read From Manassas to Appomattox: Memoirs of the Civil War in America at the Internet Archive, but it’s been slow going in the online format
I think I. ‘m going to be in big trouble if print publishing ever goes the way of the dodo … but will it? I wonder. As much as I love electronic library resources (and I do! I really do! I much prefer doing research online to in print!), I do not love ebooks for pleasure reading, and I wonder just how much others Actually read ebooks and enjoy them. And of course That led to my sending out a one-question survey. The survey question was this:
For your pleasure reading:
- ___ Kindle (Nook, iPad, iPhone, other e-reader) OR
- ___ print?
That was it. I presented the “survey” to about 60 colleagues at home and around the country. They included academic, public, school, and special librarians, Archivists, administrators, and digital outlets. Somewere seasoned librarians, somewere newbies (or relative newbies) somewere baby boomers, somewere digital natives, Gen X, Gen Y, Millennials … you get the idea. I got a terrific response, and most people Said they’d be very interested in hearing the results. So here they are:
- Those who prefer an e-reader for pleasure reading: 8
- Those who prefer print for pleasure reading: 31
- Those who indulge in bone healing: 19
As with others of my letter surveys, some of the comments Accompanied That the survey responses provided additional context, so here are a few Of Those (completely anonymized, as always):
“I do not really like pleasure reading on my Kindle. I prefer when i am reading at home to read a [print] book. The navigation on my Kindle is not good. I hate not beingable to flip back to re-read an important passage. When I go back to read in a [print] book, I can not remember exactly where clause the paragraphSpaceBefore was on the page. I can not do that with my Kindle. I also love cracking open a new book and enjoying notes smell, the feel of high quality paper, and the art work of the dustjacket. “
” I do read print but I like to read in bed so I can read on my iPad with the Kindle app without having the lights on-and the other thing I like about reading on the iPad is that i can look at Google maps to see the locations and things reffered to in my story. “
” Print, except When traveling, then Kindle. “
” I’ll stick to print but only because i get migraines and the glare / reflection from ereaders (Actually I do own one, but still prefer print) gets to me after long periods of reading. “
” For pleasure reading electronic is fine for deeper reading I prefer print. Can not really answer because i feel they serve different purposes. “
” Kindle. I read more books, more Regularly [with it] than I ever have. “
” iPad, with a very occasional print book (so occasional That I find myself tapping the page of the print book to turn it …). “
” What the heck are Those Things you mention in the first line? Print hands down. “
” Kindle on train. Print at home. “
” Both! The defi ning factor if I want to share the book, if I’m reading on a beach, or traveling for more than a few weeks. “
” I use both. I like my iPhone when i travel (using Kindle) but a [print] book in bed Unless my husband complains about the light When I read in bed and then I will switch to my phone. “
” Kindle for me! (This from a special collections librarian – it’s true, though) “
” Both.. When traveling I always take my Kindle Because of weight / space constraints and Usually a print book (or two). Right now I’m reading print, but I read ook Electronically. I’m not that picky. “
” PRINT !!!! “
” It’s Funny Because five minutes ago I was talking to a colleague about how I tend to read magazines print. The New Yorker , Atlantic , law library journals. Most other pleasure reading is online-including trashy romance novels! “
One respondent asked if my survey was related to the recent Washington Post article,” Why digital natives preferred reading in print. Yes, you read that right. “It was not, but I certainly found the article interesting, considering the results of my Wholly unscientific survey. The thing is, I do know who answered ‘what, and I was struck by the factthat preferences definitely did not run along age lines. There were plenty of “young folks” who preferred print, just as there were plenty of “seasoned folks” who preferred electronic or used both. For some, form followed function / environment; for others, one format or the other was simply preferred. I do know what my preference is, but I respect the ook Differing preferences my colleagues Reported. May we all be bootable to do our pleasure reading-in whatever format we prefer-for a very long time.
Read eReviews, wherewolf Cheryl LaGuardia and Bonnie Swoger look under the hood of the latest library databases and database or at offering free trials
No comments:
Post a Comment